What follows is a direct reply to the MaximumPC.com article at: http://www.maximumpc.com/article/features/10_things_android_does_better_iphone
This response can be called “as biased” as the original article itself, considering that someone really had to dig for just 10 things Android OS does better than iPhone OS. And these things are such a stretch, some of them are downright moronic. I own two phones. I originally purchased an iPhone 3G 8-gig, which is basically a second generation of the iPhone, and it cost me $300. Even after taking that hit out of my federal tax return, I love the phone dearly, and still consider it the coolest piece of equipment I have, it gets more use than my PC. About a year after I got the iPhone, I had to switch to Sprint, so I got an HTC Hero, which is a third-generation of it’s series, and supposedly the final true “iPhone killer” when compared to the exact model of my iPhone. The volume of how destructively wrong that assessment is can only be referred to as “WTF”. If anything, owning this piece of crap has only increased my love for the iPhone, which does everything I want a handheld device to do at least twice as good.
Keep in mind that I have not upgraded my iPhone to OS4, nor do I intend to. From what I’m told, OS4 ruins my older 3G model with lag and slowdowns, so I’m sticking with the latest release of OS3, and that is what I am using to compare to Android OS in this response-review (based solely on my experiences with the HTC Hero).
I’ll start with the “10 Things” list from Maximum PC:
1: Android can Run Multiple Apps at the Same Time
Interestingly idiotic. From just reading the text, the author pretty much punches himself in the face with this one. If the iPhone can only multitask it’s native applications, such as Mail, iPod, and Phone, then would it not stand to reason that such benefits would be directly comparable to how cool he makes it out to be that you can do things on the Android while receiving notifications (like Mail), listen to music (like on the iPod), or… well, that last part is just stupid. Gee, what I wouldn’t give to have my GPS device running full-tilt while I’m doing something else on my phone… except only I cannot think of a single instance where I would EVER need that. Fact is, the iPhone only has the capability to multitask a few select things, which are precisely the things I want it to: playing music and… well, that’s pretty much it. It’s a handheld device. I don’t have anything I need it to do in the background. If I want it to do something, I ask it to, it does, and then I’m done. If I get a phone call, the worst case is that whatever I’m doing gets “paused”, and then I go right back to it. Unlike, say, the Android, which crashes half the programs instantly upon receiving a call, often losing work. In addition, this so-called multitasking that IS possible on my HTC is spotty at best. I can’t even listen to music while doing ANYTHING else unless I want everything to lag so horrendously that I have no option but to go back and stop the music player, then dig out my app killer just to make sure it really did stop, because just stopping an application ALWAYS leaves it running full-tilt in the background, which is so ridiculous that I’ll be mentioning this moronic “feature” again later. No such problems on the iPhone.
2: Android Keeps Information Visible on Your Home Screen
Widgets on Android are a complete and utter joke, and that author (what’s his name… Paul, okay, we’ll use your first name from now on…) — Paul’s comments are the punchline to that joke. Weather widget? Yeah, okay, you slide over to it, and it freezes the phone while loading the constantly-running-and-draining-your-battery-but-oh-so-convenient weather app in the background that apparently cannot actually display the information you want it to until you swipe to that screen, at which point you’re stuck waiting for 30+ seconds while it updates it’s information because it’s still showing yesterday’s weather. When it finally updates, it couldn’t get your GPS signal right and can’t seem to retain the fact that you don’t want it to use your current GPS location to analyze the weather, but hey, at least you know the current humidity in New Jersey. Maybe you should visit there, it looks nice out. On my home screen on my iPhone is a button for the Weather Channel. I press it (without “hunting” for it), and there’s practically zero load time, maybe 5 seconds on a bad signal. Boom, the weather at the location that I last saved, along with the OPTION to either switch to another custom location or utilize GPS services to pull it up pretty much instantly for right where I’m standing. This difference between Android’s use of widgets and iPhone’s is similarly comparable across the board. (even the Android clock is slow… the CLOCK widget, for goddess’s sake, will show the last time you saw when you last swiped to it if it’s not on your first home screen, while it tries to load the CURRENT time… W.T.F.)
3: Android Has a Better App Market
When I saw the title of number 3, I nearly spit my coffee all over the screen of my iPhone. I really truly did not think for a hot second that Paul would ever go there. If there’s one thing I’ll put at the top of the list that is completely untouchable, it’s the iPhone’s App Store. Android’s Market doesn’t even come close. This is a sacrifice where true and full freedom breeds chaos and anarchy, and while moderation may not let the top-of-the-line first release through, it will almost certainly get there within a couple updates, or else that next contender WILL enter in and demolish it. Let’s start with the App Store:
In the App Store, when I search for an app, if it exists, the search is going to find it. Sure, there will be some crud in there, but for the most part it is simply the apps that do exactly what I’m looking for. How do I know? Because you go to an app and it often has many full paragraphs of descriptions about the app and it’s updates over time. Scroll down a bit and you see screenshots, often up to 6 full screenshots showing you exactly what you’ll see when using this app. Down from that is the ratings, giving an average review score that you can click on, and you are practically guaranteed to see at least one full review from someone who has actually used it. Further down is information about the creator of the app, as well as an address to check out more apps by that author/company, along with full size of the app it’s version. When you click to install it, it immediately leaves the app store, takes you to the exact location of the newly generated icon, and shows you a progress bar that tells you how it’s downloading, and when it’s installing, after which you can click-and-go. Could not possibly be easier or prettier in it’s simplicity, yet informative and practical.
And now for the Android Market: You go there, and search for an app. Good luck finding anything even related to what you’re searching for, but let’s skip past that and assume you found something that is named in such a way that it might be what you want that’s not pornographic in nature, so you go to it. If you’re LUCKY, you get a single line of text describing it, often in broken or simply downright bad english, a price tag that is probably in euros, and one of two average review scores: 1 star, or 5 stars. It has 1 star if it’s been on the Market for a while and people have actually downloaded it, and all the reviews you can find are “sux” or “downt git” with still no actual description of what it does or what’s bad about it. If it’s 5 stars, that’s because one or two people have downloaded it (probably good friends of the author), and their reviews are “works grate!” and “first!”. Did I mention no screenshots? That’s right, you have no way of knowing what it will even look like on your Android phone until after you’ve downloaded it (and likely paid for it through the requisite of converting your cash into french indochinese piastre). Once you do decide to download it, it minimizes into your notification tray, which will lag around a bit while it downloads and while you try desperately to swipe it downwards but it cannot read your touch because it’s too locked up attempting to busy itself with the download, eventually allowing you to run the app from that notification tray, from which it will disappear forever after that first load, and you’ll have to remember exactly what it’s called in order to dig it out of your app list later in order to copy over to your home screen. Dumb.
4: Android Gives You Better Notifications
After reading through this twice, I still don’t understand where the “better” comes in. Something about multitasking and home screens? Both of my phones show me what I want to see when I check for them. Both will push mail and notify me when I get one, even in the background. I’ve never experienced a moment where my life would have been better if my iPhone had informed me while I’m in the middle of a game that I have a Facebook comment. It waits for me to finish to check that silly stuff, and even then only when I want it to. I have zero problem with this.
5: Android Lets You Choose Your Hardware
This is starting to tire me out. You’re really stretching, Paul. iPhone OS runs perfectly on the phone that was designed around it. Android runs shoddily on a series of slow retro-fitted phones in order to alienate whatever percentage of poor sods decide to buy that particular brand because they were told by everyone that it was the “iPhone killer”. My hand is raised, by the way.
6: Android Lets You Choose Your Carrier
True, but the price of tea in China is down this year, Paul. Android OS certainly does not work better on Sprint than iPhone OS works on AT&T, despite what you may think of the carriers. (I have never had any problems with AT&T’s service in Michigan, but Sprint is complete ass, not that it makes any difference to the OS’s at all)
7: Android Lets You Install Custom ROMs
Paul is truly cracking me up now. It’s like watching a starving man crawl through the desert, begging for water but refusing the fountain released by Apple because it is so very blasphemous. He starts with explaining how all jailbreaking does is allow you to install pirate-apps onto your iPhone. He then starts his Android props with “Not only do Custom ROMs bring the same functionality Jailbreaking does“– Wait, stop, Paul. You can install pirate apps onto your Android phone with them? You mean the ones that don’t get through the unfiltered Market filter? Right, okay, moving on… Paul notes that you can do several things, all of which are basically a repetitive rewording of “customize your UI”. True, I can’t customize the UI on my iPhone. Lord knows I want to, because all this convenience gets so boring. How I long for a distracting and unresponsive yet fully customized UI! Oh, look, it’s my Hero. Whew!
8: Android Lets You Change Your Settings Faster
Very true! With my Android, I can put a single button on the home screen that, when pressed, will initiate WiFi and connect to my router. With iPhone, I have to hit a painstakingly long series of… 3 buttons to do it. Oh but it gets better, check this out. I can hit the WiFi button on my Android, then immediately go to my iPhone, hit Settings > Wifi > ON, then the home button, get connected, load up the browser, bring up facebook, post an update, go back home, go back into settings > WiFi > OFF, home button, then turn my iPhone off. At that final moment, the Android MIGHT have finally established a connection to my WiFi network, but only so long as I took my time with the above sequence, and only so long as I’m within, say, 14 inches of my router. But thank goodness there was that convenient button! It seemed so quick!
9: Android Does Google and Social Integration
The title here is pretty silly, because it makes me double-check that I still have Google and Facebook on my iPhone. Yep, still there. But there is the one thing that I must bow down to that seems like only a cursory mention in his description of number 9: Facebook integrating into the phone’s contact list. THAT is freakin’ awesome, and I bow down to Android for it. Certainly not a game-winner, but I definitely wish my iPhone could do that as seamlessly as my Android can.
10: Android Gives You More Options to Fit Your Budget
I bought my HTC Hero this past February, right around the time that the iPhone 3G I own went down to $99 off the shelf. Retail price for the oh-so-superior Android phone? $249. Yes, you have more options. You can roll the dice with a pricey piece of junk, or buy an iPhone and know EXACTLY what you’re getting and what it can do without taking the chance of stumbling into an overmarketed paperweight that should never have hit the shelves in the first place, just because your friends and every review site told you it had a “open source” OS and was a “good competitor” to the iPhone. I’m amazed those reviewers still have jobs. I’d be amazed if Paul still has one, too.
Further game-killers:
No games on the android. Like at all. Bounce the cow and mine the loot and crap, sure. Check out the immense, wonderfully developed games on the iPhone and you’ll see there is no comparison. Android pawns off junkware that you wouldn’t download for free on your PC. iPhone has games like Quest and Dungeon Hunter that make me wish there WAS a version of it on PC. And they run beautifully, whereas the java junker games I’ve found on Android make me feel like I’m trying to play the ASCII version of Oregon Trail on a TRS-80.
Battery life sucks on the HTC Hero. I can manage the battery life wonderfully on my iPhone and it will last a couple days on a full charge with moderate use, even after all this time. The android goes from full charge to zero in a couple hours unless I basically sit on the third party “app killer” app that loads up to kill all the apps that continuously reload themselves into the memory of the Android for NO REASON WHATSOEVER. It’s pathetic.
That’s enough for now. Perhaps on next post, I will post MY 10 things the Android OS does better. Yes, despite how biased you might think I am about my iPhone (and you’d be right), I do have a few things my HTC can do that I wish like hell my iPhone could do (only one of which was covered in MaxPC’s so-called Top 10). So I’ll switch my bias around temporarily to do that… another night.
More later.